
N.M. Cabangbang
One common sign of “aging” is when one tells stories beginning with the phrase “katong sauna” (or “in my time”), which usually means that an “old” person needs to state something that the present generation has forgotten. And this is what is happening to me now, especially when music is the topic. Stories need to be told and retold to remind the younger generation of the history of music. Most, if not all, the young ones these days have forgotten or are completely alien to the music of the previous generations. In fact, there are now just very few people that I can talk to about the music of my growing years without starting with the phrase “katong sauna.”
The last time that happened was when I had an awesome time discussing Glam Metal and the band The Darkness with my good friend Tianos Makabenta. The other time was when I was talking to Insoy Niñal about the evolution of rock from Glam Metal to Grunge.
So as not to sound old or what, I am not going to begin this article with a “katong sauna” phrase. Rather, I am just going to tell my story as it is: to explain why I hate Emo.
Emo, for some of you who do not know yet, is the new Rock genre that the kids of this decade are ardent fans of. Emo rock, according to “Rock scholars,” is mostly characterized by melodic tunes and expressive or confessional lyrics. It broke into the mainstream at the early 2000s and some of its famous bands are Dashboard Confessional and My Chemical Romance. Filipino Emo bands would be Typecast and Chicosci. Compared to pop punk, Emo is a better rock genre. So why do I hate it?
Before I expound on the answer to that question, let me touch base on a couple of the obvious points why some people dislike Emo.
Well first of all, most non-lovers of Emo hate it for the very same reason the critics hated Glam Metal before: FASHION and IMAGE. A lot of people do not understand the eyeliners, the thick jackets (worn even on a sunny day), and long side-swept bangs. However, if you come to think of it, people fear and hate what they do not understand. This is a natural reaction. In fact, all rock genres in their early years also were hated and misunderstood. Emo is just experiencing what the other genres experienced at their musical infancy. When Poison or Skid Row wore make-up, a lot of people viewed them as distasteful cross-dressers. When Nirvana and Pearl Jam chose to wear their hair short, hard-core rock fans thought that the image was “not rock enough.” Before the wonderful union of rap and metal, respective followers of both genres used to despise each other. But when Rage Against the Machine and Limp Bizkit came into the picture, these warring factions kissed and made up. So that is how it is. So even if I do not get the fascination over Emo fashion, this would not be a completely valid reason for hating them.
I, too, just have come to the conclusion that different generations will always produce new music. No matter how loud their music or farfetched their fashion would be; it does not matter as long as they own it. The youth will always need something to call their own, and for the youth today, they own Emo.
So it is not good for us “older” people, to make fun or pass judgement on Emo. I mean, remember the time when we were the young ones? Our parents and different institutions laughed at us. They criticized us too.
So if it’s not the fashion and style, then do I hate Emo for their musicianship? Hating this genre for their musical abilities may be a valid reason. I mean, it’s no secret that some bands can’t play well enough in live sessions to save their lives. We’ve all been there: on the album, the vocals are flawless. And then here comes that live concert and the vocalist croaks while singing that one song you happen to like. It’s devastating, I tell you.
And how about the lyrics? I’ve heard some people comment that Emo lyrics are too cliché. Heartbreaks, suicides or rejection; a lot of past rock genres have already tackled those. So, Emo’s core theme is nothing new at all.
Before you nod your head in agreement, let me remind you that that a lot of people questioned the talents of Punk rockers back then. Most of Punk rockers were considered to have below-average musicianship, when compared to the dominating hard rock genre back then. For Punk, the seemingly lack of musical skills was a style, not an excuse. Today, however, Punk Rock is one of the most respected genres out there.
And sure, Emo is guilty of having cliché lyrics. I’m talking about “hearts getting torn into bits” or “the world seems better off without me” shticks. However, let me point out that there are indeed a chosen few in the Emo genre that have good, if not, awesome lyrics. Just try listening to My Chemical Romance or Taking Back Sunday. Their titles and lyrics such as “I Brought You My Bullets, You Brought Me Your Love” or “I’m an addict for dramatics I confuse the two for love” are a proof of lyrical talent. I mean, I wish I came up with those! So my take on this is that, lyrically, the Emo genre has something to offer and the truly talented bands in the genre deliver that.
Moreover, we also need to remember that every rock genre always has a bad apple in the mix. For Glam Rock, Bon Jovi and Def Leppard were the best while their worst were Stryper, White Lion, and Extreme. For Grunge, the top four would be Pearl Jam, Alice in Chains, Soundgarden, and Nirvana; while the band at the bottom would be Creed.
It is clear then, that all rock genres have their fair share of great bands and bad apples at the same time. It would be very unfair to throw that criticism only to the Emo genre.
Alright, now we’ve established that I do not hate Emo for their image and musicianship. So why do I hate this genre?
Well, I dislike Emo for the reason that it uses the word “Emo” (short for “emotional”) as the name of their genre. It is as if they are the only genre that is expressive or thought-provoking. I mean, c’mon! Emo songs are not the first to sing about feeling. Both Rap and Heavy metal were already venting their angst before these Emo kids hit puberty. Kurt Cobain and Chris Cornell were already dealing with depression, rejection, and suicide in Grunge rock. If the kids of this decade would just have the chance to listen to lyrics that Alice in Chains, Soundgarden, and Rollins Band had to offer, then maybe they would see my point.
All music are expressive and emotional, it is not only Emo that should have that title. “Emo” is a wrong singular label in an industry that thrives on translating feelings and emotions. And I hate the term “Emo” to be exclusive to just one genre because I feel that it discounts the legacy of other musicians.
So yes, I hate Emo because it is called such. But that does not necessarily mean that I will stop listening to the genre, especially to the bands that I happen to respect. I’m here for the music and not the labels. Good music is good music whatever its name is.
cebu city, cebu, Philippines, cebu writer, cebu blogger, cebu art, cebu music, cebu music scene, midweek music sessions, bangbang, paltik, cabangbang, noel, bangbangthe13th, Philippine art, Philippine politics, Philippine society, Philippine entertainment, Philippine sports,